The Knowing Blandness of the ‘Dream Home Makeover’ Aesthetic

Welcome to Residence Watching, a column concerning the wild and wooly world of renovation tv from a self-proclaimed skilled within the style.

Very like pornography, a Studio McGee inside while you see it. Shea McGee, the brains behind the operation, who infamously began her firm after gaining a following posting her first dwelling’s rework on Instagram, favors various shades of white, accented with neutrals and pure supplies. Colour is off limits, except it’s darkish grey, black, or, now and again, a deep, deep navy or evergreen. The ceilings are sometimes white, adorned with reclaimed wooden beams, and if the house permits, vaulted. The McGees favor ceramics, rough-hewn wooden, and have by no means met a sheepskin rug they didn’t like. When seen in mixture, the aesthetic is unsatisfactory principally in that it’s unremarkable, particularly within the type of interiors the McGees usually work with—large new builds, the place your entire home is a clean canvas, able to be designed in Shea’s exacting aesthetic imaginative and prescient. 

Nowhere is that this extra evident than within the dwelling of Liz and Neil, the couple featured within the third episode of Netflix’s Dream Home Makeover, which is now in its third season. The shoppers in query are repeat clients; the McGees labored on their Park Metropolis dwelling, and have been tapped to lend their magic contact to their second dwelling in Southern California, which seems to be simply as massive as the primary. Liz and Neil have three youngsters and are unfathomably rich, although what they do isn’t talked about. It’s on this house that the McGees outline their aesthetic imaginative and prescient—”upscale Napa farmhouse,” Shea says, which sounds extra like a advertising time period than an precise design alternative.

What this interprets to is giant architectural gestures that convey wealth—vaulted ceilings within the kitchen and the lounge, a “wine room” with built-in bookshelves that meet the ceiling, and different thrives that talk to the huge quantities of cash this couple should have to take care of their bonus dwelling. It’s not that any of those design decisions are wherever near hideous, per se—Studio McGee’s signature look is quieter than the Property Brothers, however extra subtle that Chip and Joanna Gaines’s farmhouse stylish. Staged as they’re, although, the areas designed by Studio McGee lack any discernible character. Youngsters get large bedrooms with queen-size beds; each kitchen has an infinite island, whether or not or not the house really wants it. (Whereas most kitchens may use an island, not each house wants one. Understanding this distinction is essential.)

There’s nothing notably of curiosity for me in Studio McGee’s most high-end designs. (Their Goal line, which incorporates this very nice quilt, is way more my pace.) However regardless of this truth, I’ve watched each accessible episode of their present, normally in a single sitting. What’s fascinating concerning the third season, which not too long ago began streaming, is that the McGees have crossed a really particular dwelling renovation actuality TV rubicon, the place they’re now being sought out by individuals who have seen what they’ll do on TV and need it for themselves. It’s this distinction that makes the present that rather more fascinating; watching human beings settle into their roles as commodities is at all times a visit. Shea and her husband Syd are striving to be personalities very similar to Ben and Erin Napier and Chip and Joanna Gaines are, however as a result of Netflix lacks HGTV’s oomph, they’ve the house to experiment with their public-facing personalities, because the stakes are decrease.  

Fortunately, although, their dynamic as a pair and as enterprise companions nonetheless has somewhat edge to it, which is probably going a advantage of being on Netflix relatively than HGTV. Syd McGee, the husband, usually wears an expression within the confessionals that appears like he’s being held hostage, however is form of okay with it. What he does for the corporate that bears his identify is unclear, however one assumes it’s form of vital and certain vital. (Actually, he’s CEO.) When Shea’s palms are in each single pot, and the outcomes of their renovations are completely in line with her conceptions, Syd desires of a  life in Southern California, on the seashore, with early morning surf classes and bonfires at sundown. As an alternative, the present jokes, he’s chained to his spouse’s aspect, indispensable in a approach that’s by no means outlined.

However like several good dwelling design present, the actual principal character just isn’t the couple doing the renovations, however the finish outcomes. For the 2 years that I’ve watched this program, I’ve tried to dial down what one may name this aesthetic, which is each particular and generic—like each different high-end Airbnb itemizing available on the market, or an antiseptic boutique lodge that prides itself on design. However it wasn’t till midway by this season when one of many McGee’s shoppers hit the nail on the top. “It’s upscale-looking,” a lady says of her newly-renovated basement, which is split into three clear “zones” meant to delineate what sorts of leisure actions ought to happen there and why. It’s not fairly upscale, however suggestive of it as an alternative, a unique type of new cash aesthetic. But when given the selection between Studio McGee’s all-white fantasia and a large McMansion match for a Actual Housewife of New Jersey, I’d take gold restroom fixtures and Travertine tile any day. On the very least, it’s enjoyable.   

Prime photograph courtesy of Netflix.

Extra TV this manner:

‘How to Build a Sex Room’ Has Some Heart

In ‘The Queen of Versailles Reigns Again,’ an Unfinished Mega-Mansion Is Not a Home

Home Renovation Shows Meet Cute with Romance Novels

Posted by


Welcome, you are reading the article The Knowing Blandness of the ‘Dream Home Makeover’ Aesthetic published date 2022-08-16. Thank you for visiting Corarchitecture

Leave a Comment